Case Document

FAST AND FURIOUS: HOW ANTERAJA DELIVERS ITS PROMISES

The case study discusses Anteraja, a courier company which operates throughout Indonesia. The case highlights the strategies that Anteraja has implemented so far and how they have performed in the Indonesian market. These teaching notes aim to provide a guideline for a lecturer or facilitator to deliver the Anteraja case study. The first part of the case delivery will enable the students to familiarize themselves with the case and the company as described in the case study. The second part of the teaching note will provide options that a facilitator can take to conduct different class activities, such as a question-and-answer session, debate, gamification, or simulation.

Author

Dr. Adilla Anggraeni, B.Bus., MBA.

Dr. Adilla Anggraeni, B.Bus., MBA.

Iston Dwija Utama, S.E., M.A.B.

Iston Dwija Utama, S.E., M.A.B.

Dr. Darjat Sudrajat, S.E., M.M., CSCA, CSCM

Dr. Darjat Sudrajat, S.E., M.M., CSCA, CSCM

BLIBLI: THE GIANT ECOMMERCE DANCING ON THE STOCK FLOOR

Blibli is one of the leading e-commerce businesses in Indonesia. On 8 November 2022 Blibli conducted an initial public offering or IPO in the Jakarta Stock Exchange. With a total market capitalization of IDR 53.3 trillion, Blibli is the second largest Internet-unicorn in Asia Pacific to go IPO in 2022 and the fifth largest IPO in history in Indonesia. On the first day of trading, the price of Blibli did not move; it was stagnant at a price of IDR 450 per share. The company used the proceeds to repay their debts and expand the business, as it acquired tiket.com and collaborated with Ranch Market. From its prospectus, the proceeds were used to develop new products, cover operational expenses, improve the supporting technology facilities, and do other business actions needed.   The interesting question is how will Blibli do after the IPO? Will its share price roar or slump like the first movers, Bukalapak and Goto?

Author

Dr. Ir. Dewi Tamara, MM., MS.

Dr. Ir. Dewi Tamara, MM., MS.

Dr. Anita Maharani, S.E., M.M.

Dr. Anita Maharani, S.E., M.M.

Miranda Tanjung, Ph.D

Miranda Tanjung, Ph.D

A SHARIA HOTEL CHAIN: STORY OF ARABIA HOSPITALITY GROUP

The story of the Arabia Hospitality Group centers on the Grand Arabia Hotel in Banda Aceh, Indonesia. Established in 2017 and later acquired by the Arabia Hospitality Group in 2021, it's strategically located near the Baiturrahman Grand Mosque. The group's focus is on luxurious hotels adhering to Sharia law, with over 7 locations across Sumatra. They offer upscale accommodation targeting medium to upper segments, pricing rooms from 800,000 to 4,900,000 rupiah. Competition mainly arises from large hotel brands like Accor, Four Seasons, and local brands, though the strict adherence to Sharia law in the region discourages some major brands from entering the Banda Aceh market. However, the hotel faces human resource challenges, notably high turnover due to various factors. Issues range from infrastructure discomfort (power outages, poor internet) to employees' reluctance to adhere to Sharia law's standards, causing disciplinary problems. Potential solutions include providing comfortable accommodations for employees, addressing infrastructure issues, conducting more informative sessions about the importance of Sharia law compliance, and offering computer literacy training. In conclusion, while the Arabia Hospitality Group presents a unique approach catering to Sharia law conformity, addressing employee needs and reinforcing the significance of Sharia law adherence within the company culture are vital for sustained success in this niche market.

Author

Dr. Sekar Wulan Prasetyaningtyas, S.Si., M.Pd.

Dr. Sekar Wulan Prasetyaningtyas, S.Si., M.Pd.

Marketing Year 2023

FRESHBOX UNVEILED: REVOLUTIONIZING THE FOOD CHAIN FROM THE FARM TO TABLE AND BEYOND

Freshbox is an e-grocery platform founded in 2018 by Matthew James. He envisioned bringing fresh produce from farmers to consumers’ tables directly, thus the concept ‘farm to table’ was introduced. Certainly, when the COVID-19 pandemic hit in late 2019, the e-grocery industry soared and Freshbox was able to grow significantly. They began to open offline stores starting with the first one in Mall of Indonesia. Despite the promising industry trend, the fact that the pandemic was coming to an end and customers started going back offline posed a threat to Freshbox. Other e-grocery platforms began to falter one by one, including the big players as well. The shifts in consumer behavior have forced Freshbox to go to survival mode. What strategies should Freshbox implement to survive in the constantly changing market?

Author

Dr. Adilla Anggraeni, B.Bus., MBA.

Dr. Adilla Anggraeni, B.Bus., MBA.

Bryna Meivitawanli, SE, B.Sc., MBA, Ph.D.

Bryna Meivitawanli, SE, B.Sc., MBA, Ph.D.

KOPI KENANGAN’S METEORIC RISE TO UNICORN STATUS

In a remarkably short period, Kopi Kenangan has transcended the Indonesian coffee market, elevating itself to unicorn status and reshaping the way people perceive affordable, high-quality coffee. The company’s meteoric rise can be attributed to its visionary founders, a keen understanding of market needs, and an unwavering commitment to its employees and customers, even amidst the most challenging of times. As Kopi Kenangan continues its expansion across Southeast Asia and prepares to enter the public market, it serves as a testament to the power of innovation and resilience in the face of adversity. Kopi Kenangan has successfully positioned itself as a formidable competitor within the coffee food and beverage industry through its commitment to quality, affordable pricing, and customer satisfaction. Despite facing challenges from competing chains and potential risks from supplier and customer bargaining positions, the company has managed to maintain an impressive growth trajectory by implementing Total Quality Management practices and ensuring the highest quality standards across its extensive network of outlets. Kopi Kenangan’s scale-up strategy revolves around several key principles: having a deliberate pricing strategy, adopting new retail concepts, and creating high social media engagement. These tactics have allowed Kopi Kenangan to differentiate itself from its competitors and capture a significant share of the market in a relatively short amount of time. As Kopi Kenangan continues to scale up, it can build on these strategies to expand its presence and maintain its competitive edge in the coffee, food, and beverage industry.

Author

Dicky Hida Syahchari, S.T., M.M., Ph.D

Dicky Hida Syahchari, S.T., M.M., Ph.D

Dr. Sambudi Hamali, S.T, M.M, CPLM

Dr. Sambudi Hamali, S.T, M.M, CPLM

Santika Syaravina, S.Ds, M.A.B.

Santika Syaravina, S.Ds, M.A.B.

Marketing Year 2023

FASHIONING THE FUTURE: ZALORA`S OMNICHANNEL TRIUMPH IN SOUTHEAST ASIA

In the vibrant tapestry of Southeast Asia's retail scene, Zalora emerges as a luminary, navigating the intricate dance of digital transformation with aplomb. As 2023 unfolds, the fashion industry witnesses a seismic shift towards digital, and amidst this tumult, Zalora's journey offers a masterclass in strategic evolution. Zalora's inception in 2012 was marked by a bold vision - to integrate online and offline retail experiences seamlessly. This pioneering omnichannel approach, though met with skepticism, set the stage for a retail revolution in Southeast Asia. But Zalora didn't stop there. Recognizing the diverse tapestry of its customer base, the company pivoted towards a data-driven personalization strategy. By harnessing the power of AI and machine learning, Zalora transformed its customer interactions, ensuring that each touchpoint, be it web, mobile, or email, resonated with individual preferences and buying stages. This strategic shift underscores the profound impact of personalization in shaping retail strategies, enhancing customer engagement, and fostering loyalty. Zalora's strategic foray into digital payment solutions was audacious and timely in a region dominated by cash-on-delivery transactions. This move, necessitated by logistical challenges and the quest for operational efficiency, showcased Zalora's proactive approach to addressing market challenges. The company's investment in this domain streamlined the payment process and enhanced customer convenience, setting a new benchmark for e-commerce operations in the region. Beyond the digital realm, Zalora crafted tangible, memorable customer experiences. Initiatives like pop-up stores, fashion shows, and community events transformed Zalora from a mere online retailer to a fashion community curator. The #ZALORAYA2023 campaign stands as a testament to this, turning a traditional shopping experience into a cultural extravaganza, reaching millions, and solidifying Zalora's position as an experiential retail powerhouse. Zalora's narrative offers invaluable insights into the future of retail in Southeast Asia. From its omnichannel prowess to its emphasis on personalization, its innovative payment solutions, and its experiential retail endeavors, Zalora stands as a beacon, illuminating the path for retailers in the digital age.

Author

Sukma Putra, SE., M.Ed.

Sukma Putra, SE., M.Ed.

Dr. Peri Akbar Manaf, B.Sc., MBA.

Dr. Peri Akbar Manaf, B.Sc., MBA.

Baba Rafi - Dari Lantai Trotoar ke Lantai Bursa (From Sidewalk to Trading Floor): The Successful Story of SMEs

In 2022, PT Sari Kreasi Boga (SKB) Food (their main brand is Turkey Kebab Baba Rafi) listed its shares on the Indonesia Stock Exchange.  SKB Food is a new color for the Indonesian capital market industry. SKB Food is an MSME that can transform into a corporation so that it can conduct an IPO. Success does not come in the blink of an eye.  Nilamsari experiences 19 years of ups and downs personally and professionally. But with her grit, the business flourished.  also,ting the business with a simple burger cart on the sidewalk, with her perseverance and innovation, Baba Rafi expanded internationally not only Southeast Asia, but also to South Asia and Europe. With franschising and horizontal integration, SKB growth extensively. SKB also embraced collaboration in their business strategy.  With IPO, however, the challenge is the next expansion.  Should they stay in the same industry with vertical and integral expansion, or should they diversify?

Author

Dr. drh. Diena Dwidienawati Tjiptadi, MM

Dr. drh. Diena Dwidienawati Tjiptadi, MM

Marketing Year 2023

A NEW ERA OF TELEVISION: WeTV’s IMPACT ON THE INDUSTRY’S LANDSCAPE

WeTV allows you to view TV episodes, movies, animation, and variety shows on internet-connected devices. The company's earlier success came from its different approach toward the international market. WeTV is the subsidiary of Tencent Video, having all Tencent Video’s features but with localization. WeTV produces its own original local series, local marketing strategy, and localized language and interface to give the most optimum experience for the users. Entering the market as a mixed profit business model, WeTV supplies free content for the audience with ads and a subscription version to watch earlier episodes than users that are using the free account. This type of business model fits the Indonesian market as they have greater willingness to watch ads as an exchange for free content. But this also limited WeTV footsteps for the past year, WeTV has been popular among the middle-low-income segments but now, as WeTV is more eager to generate profit through subscription and lessen the role of advertising income, it did bring critics to the platform. Moreover, as newer OTT comes through the industry, WeTV is not the only one providing local original content. Giant players such as Netflix, VIU, Amazon Prime, and Disney+ Hotstar have also started to make their original local productions. Moreover, many local competitors also bring more cultural fit and differentiation that threatens WeTV’s position in the market. From a commercial perspective, how can WeTV balance audience interest and succeed in this dynamic relationship in the market to last over time? Could WeTV beat its competitors and be the market leader in Indonesia OTT market? What changes in Strategy WeTV should implement to better fit the consumer?

Author

Aryo Bismo , SE, MM.

Aryo Bismo , SE, MM.

BANK SYARIAH INDONESIA : MERGER TO REALIZE THE HOPE OF THE COUNTRY

On Monday, February 1, 2021, President Joko Widodo inaugurated PT Bank Syariah Indonesia Tbk. (BSI) at the State Palace, Jakarta. This inauguration was a historic day for the development of the Islamic economy in Indonesia, which is a country with the largest Muslim population in the world. BSI is the result of a merger between PT Bank BRIsyariah Tbk, PT Bank Syariah Mandiri and PT Bank BNI Syariah. The merger permit was issued by OJK through letter Number: SR-3/PB.1/2021, which allowed the name change from PT Bank BRIsyariah Tbk to PT Bank Syariah Indonesia Tbk. The talk about the merger of the three government Islamic banks has been going on since 2015 with no clear realization. However, in March 2020, BUMN Minister Erick Thohir appointed Hery Gunardi, Deputy Director of Bank Mandiri at the time, as Chairman of the Project Management Office (PMO) for the merger of three Islamic owned banks. of BUMN. Hery Gunardi has a background and experience in overseeing the merger process during the formation of Bank Mandiri in 1998-1999. The merger and increase in value of the Islamic Bank began in early March 2020 and took about 11 months. During this period, there were several processes that needed to be gone through, from due diligence, signing of the merger deed, filing information, and obtaining permits from the OJK. BSI had assets worth IDR 240 trillion with a core capital of more than IDR 22.6 trillion, which placed the company in the list of the 7 largest banks in Indonesia in terms of assets. The financing reached IDR 157 billion with third party funds (DPK) reaching IDR 157 billion. BSI is expected to become one of the 10 largest Islamic banks in the world in terms of market capitalization in the next 5 years. The composition of shareholders in the merged bank was PT Bank Mandiri (BMRI) at 51.2 percent, PT Bank Negara Indonesia (BNI) at 25 percent, PT Bank Rakyat Indonesia or (BBRI) at 17.4 percent, DPLK BRI - Sharia Shares at 2 percent, and the public 4.4 percent. The shareholding structure was based on the calculation of the valuation of each of the banks participating in the merger. BSI was expected to enhance Islamic financial services and products in Indonesia. The sharia economy is becoming increasingly important in Indonesia because the majority of the population embraces Islam. Bank Syariah Indonesia was also expected to help boost the Indonesian economy as a whole.The merger of the three Islamic banks was also expected to overcome the capitalization problems occurring in the Islamic banking sector in Indonesia. With the combined strength of these three state-owned Islamic banks, it was expected to strengthen the position of the Islamic financial industry in Indonesia and promote more inclusive economic growth. Furthermore, BSI was expected to attract more customers to use Islamic financial products and services in Indonesia. In addition to raising public awareness of Islamic finance, Bank Syariah Indonesia was expected to make an important contribution to the development of the Islamic economy in Indonesia. However, as with all newly formed companies, BSI faced several challenges and risks. Some of these include increased competition with Islamic and other conventional banks, compliance with strict regulations and standards, and preparation to deal with various operational and financial risks. In an effort to overcome these challenges, BSI needed to strengthen risk management and ensure compliance with strict regulations and standards. In addition, BSI also needed to continue to innovate and improve its sharia financial products and services so that they remain relevant and can compete with other banks. Overall, the merger of three state-owned Islamic banks to become Bank Syariah Indonesia was expected to strengthen the position of the Islamic finance industry in Indonesia and help drive more inclusive economic growth in the country. However, these startups faced various challenges and risks and must strengthen risk management and continue to innovate to remain relevant and competitive in the growing Islamic financial market.

Author

Dicky Hida Syahchari, S.T., M.M., Ph.D

Dicky Hida Syahchari, S.T., M.M., Ph.D

Dr. Maria Grace Herlina, S.Sos., M.M.

Dr. Maria Grace Herlina, S.Sos., M.M.

Marketing Year 2023

OMNICHANNEL SHOWSTOPPERS: DISSECTING THE OMNICHANNEL STRATEGIES OF MATAHARI AND MAP GROUP IN INDONESIA`S DYNAMIC MARKETPLACE

Two retail giants dominate Indonesia's bustling and vibrant retail scene, Matahari Department Store and MAP Group. These formidable competitors, each with their strengths and unique market offerings, are embroiled in an exciting battle for retail supremacy. As the market evolved and consumer tastes change, both companies have adopted an omnichannel strategy to stay ahead of the curve and win Indonesian shoppers' hearts (and wallets). As the two companies try to win their respective markets, some interesting evidence is unfolding from their respective omnichannel strategies. From seamlessly integrating online and offline channels to innovative use of personalization and data-driven decision-making, these leading retailers are helping their customers stay engaged and satisfied and get more. However, there is another type of customer. This type of customer is their investor. In this case study, we explore the competitive landscape of the Indonesian retail industry, focusing on two retail giants, Matahari Department Store, and MAP Group, through the lens of an investor. As both companies strive to excel in the rapidly evolving market, they have adopted omnichannel strategies to stay ahead of the curve, enhance customer experience, and drive growth. The case delves into both companies' financial performance, market share, brand strength, and competitive positioning. It also examines the effectiveness of their respective omnichannel strategies, which are designed to address the unique challenges of the Indonesian retail market, such as competition from e-commerce, poor infrastructure, limited consumer access, and supply chain inefficiencies. The case study highlights the importance of analyzing various factors, including the relationship between information on the merits of each company's financial performance, omnichannel strategy effectiveness, market share, brand strength, or competitive positioning, to make informed investment decisions. By comparing the omnichannel approaches and financial performance of Matahari Department Store and MAP Group, investors can gain valuable insights into their respective strengths and weaknesses. Through this investor's perspective, the case study invites readers to evaluate and contrast the investment potential of these two retail titans in Indonesia's dynamic and competitive retail industry. Ultimately, the case study aims to equip investors with the knowledge to identify the most compelling investment opportunity between Matahari Department Store and MAP Group as they navigate the challenges and capitalize on the growth opportunities in the fast-growing Indonesian retail sector.

Author

Dr. Peri Akbar Manaf, B.Sc., MBA.

Dr. Peri Akbar Manaf, B.Sc., MBA.

Miranda Tanjung, Ph.D

Miranda Tanjung, Ph.D

Sandy Setiawan S.E., M.M.

Sandy Setiawan S.E., M.M.

1 2 3 19